cropped-ropp-logo-purple-on-transparent

Port Phillip Matters

The Cosmopolitan Hotel Redevelopment: Who is Standing up for St Kilda Residents?

Author: Claire (St Kilda resident)

Cosmo_1

The existing Cosmopolitan Hotel is hardly an architectural masterpiece, and few residents would argue that the site should never be redeveloped. But the State Government’s approval of a seven-storey, 204-room hotel, with food and drink premises and a rooftop venue accommodating up to 200 patrons, raises some very real questions about the impact on the surrounding neighbourhood.

I have skin in the game. I live nearby, raised concerns during the planning process and received the State Government’s correspondence confirming the approval. These concerns are shared by many of my neighbours, who will be living with the consequences long after the developers have moved on.

Residents have not felt heard. Port Phillip Councillors voted unanimously in May to object to the proposal, raising concerns about its height, setbacks, overshadowing and impact on the area’s residential and heritage character. The Minister for Planning proceeded with approval despite Council’s objections and recommendations.

We are constantly told Victoria is in a housing crisis, yet this development provides no additional permanent housing, affordable homes or long-term rental accommodation. It provides hotel rooms. With another hotel opening on Fitzroy Street, it is fair to ask what public benefit justifies this scale of development in an established residential neighbourhood. It certainly won’t solve the housing crisis.

Then there’s traffic and parking. Residents are already struggling to find a park, even on a relatively quiet night. Finding one in St Kilda can resemble The Hunger Games with indicators. Now add hotel guests, staff, restaurant customers, function patrons, taxis, rideshares and deliveries. Where will they all go when the basement parking is full? The overflow will inevitably find its way into already congested residential streets.

The rooftop may have restricted hours, but hospitality and function facilities can operate until 1am. Noise, traffic and patrons arriving and leaving will affect the people living nearby.

I acknowledge Council has used the planning avenues available to it and formally objected. But residents need to know that our elected representatives will continue to stand up for us. Does political alignment between our Council and the State Government make it harder to challenge what Spring Street wants, even when it conflicts with what our neighbourhood needs?

A letter of objection is too easy for the Minister to dismiss. It is unacceptable that the Planning Amendment Act 2026 gives the Minister complete control over planning decisions. We expect our local Councillors and Member of Parliament to publicly challenge the State when bad planning decisions are made.

We are not anti-development. We simply want development that respects the people and neighbourhood already here. The State has made its decision, but our community should not be expected to simply accept the consequences.

We live here. We deserve to be represented.

Port Phillip Matters

cropped-ropp-logo-purple-on-transparent

Our local Port Phillip Matters newspaper keeps you up to date on community sports, school events, local personalities, local pets, with real community spirit.