Any discussion on homelessness, drug-affected individuals, and those with mental health issues must recognise the principle of competing rights. Too often, the rights of a small disruptive minority are prioritised at the expense of the broader community. Rights are rarely absolute; they must be balanced with responsibilities and the rights of others. This is consistent with the Victorian Charter of Human Rights, which allows reasonable limits to protect community safety and wellbeing.

Cr Rod Hardy’s February 2025 motion on camping laws sought to update local provisions so police and council officers could address antisocial and unsafe behaviour in public spaces. Importantly, the motion did not propose fines or criminalisation of the homeless, despite political claims to the contrary. It simply aimed to bring Port Phillip into line with 78 of 79 other Victorian municipalities, giving authorities tools to manage threatening behaviour, obstruction, and unsafe camping in retail precincts. Disappointingly, the May 2025 roundtable rejected these changes, even though Victoria Police supported them.

Genuinely homeless people are a small subset of rough sleepers as many have accommodation but prefer gathering on the streets to be close to nefarious activities. The proposed change to camping local laws aims to target the antisocial and abusive behaviours links to the encampments along with social services assistance.

Statistically, homelessness in Port Phillip affects less than 1 in 1,000 residents. Yet its impact is concentrated in areas like Acland and Fitzroy Streets, where disruptive behaviours erode safety, deter foot traffic, and contribute to retail decline. Retailers and residents alike have rights — to safe streets, thriving businesses, and a welcoming environment. Without action, our high streets risk becoming magnets for antisocial behaviour and economic decay.

The challenge is not about punishment but about balance. Council must acknowledge that while social support and housing pathways are essential, so too are practical camping laws. These measures would complement, not replace, compassion. Residents are calling for cleaner, safer streets — more than 1,600 have already signed petitions demanding action.

As one resident succinctly put it: “This motion is about protection, not punishment — ensuring officers and police have the tools to address those who threaten community safety, while also providing outreach services for those in need. It’s a collaborative approach that balances safety, support, and human rights, making our streets safer for all.”

If you have not already signed the Safer Streets petition then you should do so now – no donation is required:

https://www.change.org/p/sign-the-petition-for-safer-streets-in-port-phillip